Brendan Rodgers’s Carroll-conundrum

Brendan Rodgers needs to tread carefully. Despite learning part of his trade under the most media-savvy coach of all in Jose Mourinho, he has taken a few overly hasty steps in his handling of the Andy Carroll affair that could yet come back to haunt him. His recent about-face regarding Carroll’s utility to his plans (“he can fit into how I want to play…I’m certainly not wishing to push him out of the door”) has come off as indecision from a man who only last week implied that Carroll had no place in his tactical vision for Liverpool and would be better off seeking a loan route out of the club.

It is all very well for Rodgers to wish to stamp his authority on Liverpool early on by demonstrating firm commitment to his cherished 4-3-3 and acting decisively regarding the club’s most contentious player, but if Carroll cannot be moved on to everyone’s satisfaction and Liverpool fail to make a winning start, Rodgers’s unnecessary granting of the impression upon the public that there is an unsolvable problem between him and Carroll will be held up as the reason for his failure. Every occasion on which Carroll comes off the bench, fails to perform on the pitch, or doesn’t even make the squad, will haunt Liverpool’s team and Rodgers for as long as it needs them to adapt to a radically new system in 4-3-3 and start silencing critics with results. Doubt is easier and faster to spread than faith, and it would be catastrophic for Rodgers if the fans or players began forming opinions of him based on the media’s negative portrayal of his problems with Carroll. That would translate to a critical reluctance on the part of the players to help inculcate the 4-3-3, and the longer that takes, the more chance the swell of criticism would grow and the potentially exciting things Rodgers could offer Liverpool could be buried under their £35 million problem. Carroll does not look like a person who makes things easy for those who stand up to him, and after Rodgers’s ill-advised comments, his continued presence at Liverpool could overshadow everything he seeks to build at his new club.

Andre Villas-Boas’s travails at Chelsea serve as a useful reminder to Rodgers of the pitfalls of being a young manager at a club with history and an inclination for snap judgements. As a young manager seeking to implement a drastically new system, he needed players on his side and results to go his way for belief to grow and conformity to follow. Instead, Chelsea had an indifferent first half of the season and his falling out with Frank Lampard and other senior players became more of an issue than the good work he had to offer. Rodgers needs to avoid the same impulsiveness on all fronts of his management approach if he is to bring longevity and change to Liverpool.

4 thoughts on “Brendan Rodgers’s Carroll-conundrum

  1. Good read as ever buddy. You’re being very coy on Arsenal though? Would be interesting to read your thoughts on Arsenal’s chances up ahead and how they can cope in a post-apocalyptic era where there is no RVP and only Gervinho’s weird hairline.

  2. Wheyyyy. Yeah, one thing I’m discovering about blog formats is that older posts can very quickly disappear from view. I’ll let you know whenever I write about Arsenal and I suspect, as the season draws closer and the tussle for RVP and to buy the new players they want intensifies, there’ll be a lot to say.

    One thing about Arsenal is that they never wrap up their summer business of buying and selling quickly. At the moment, I think they need to add at least one quality attacking midfield/forward (rumour has it they were chasing a very good Spanish player called Santi Cazorla), before they can start looking to the non-RVP era without any great degree of trepidation. I’ll expand on all these thoughts – plus what I think about the Arsenal players’ changing mental appreciation of what lies ahead of them – in another post fo sho’.

    Oh, and Gervinho’s hairline? It’s a fascinating thing isn’t it? Much more enjoyable to ponder that than the other mystery of why he promises so much in front of goal and delivers so little currently.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s